Mystery Mario Party Cupcake Challenge

Birt 26 jan 2021
This mystery Mario Party cupcake challenge made us miss the ghost pepper chocolate tbh. We're on Twitch now! Check us out every Monday, Wednesday, Friday at
This video was shot with a very limited crew. All cast & crew followed all CDC and California COVID-19 precautions and filming guidelines.
Punch that bell icon so you'll know when we add a new episode!
Ian Hecox: ianhecox
Shayne Topp: shaynetopp
Damien Haas: damienhaas
Matt Raub: mattraub
Sarah Whittle: rudeunicorns
Spencer Agnew: spennser
Tommy Bowe: tomeybones
Kimmy Jimenez: kimmydoesstuff
Vice President, Unscripted: Matt Raub
Technical Producer: Mark Raub
Editor: Spencer Agnew
Producer: Layne Pavoggi
Tech Director: Mark Raub
DP: Brennan Iketani
Camera: Dustin Bloodgood
Sound Mixer: Greg Jones
Art Director: Cassie Vance
Art Coordinator: Yasmeen Mughal
Art Assistant: Alex Aguilar
GFX: Brittany Metz
Content Manager: Kiana Parker
Stage Manager: David Hill
Executive Assistant: Sammie Miller
Watch Addison Rae isn't real:
Watch Among Us, but with the same imposter every time:
Watch Untitled Goose Game ft. our discount doppelgangers:
Watch Who's The Best Imposter?:
Subscribe To Smosh Games:
Follow Us:
Instagram: smoshgames
Facebook: smoshgames
Twitter: smoshgames

Check Out Our Other Smosh Channels:
Smosh Pit:


  • I love tommy inspecting Spencer’s discarded cupcake

  • Hijikata is living in demien's body both love mayo😂😂

  • OJ Simpson was drafted by the Bills in 1969, so therefore, Shayne and Ian are the best Bills team possible. Such a great back

  • Holy fuck Matt raub lookin way better

  • When the wiggler got angry it really jumpscared me

  • Sarah i love your hair color. I might do similar with shades of purple 😍😍😍

  • Danm Matt rob lost weight

  • I'm so confused. I saw Mystery Cupcake Challenge on the first stream and it is exactly like this yet Ian still has blonde hair here and different clothes. Everyone else is exactly the same and it is so creepy watching this.

  • Tommy: *Oh, It’s Hollow🧁* Spencer: *Same*

  • It is also can be speculoos in Holland as well but both are incredible cookies

  • Actually it speculoos and it is supposed to be speculaas which is an amazing cookie from Holland it’s amazing

  • matt raub be lookin real good tho

  • Feel like shayne actually doesn’t like Spencer

  • at first i wasnt so sure about spencer, but hes honestly starting to grow on me.

  • water, fire, earth, and air. .. that's what u should fill the cupcakes with

  • My first idea for the last cupcake was cyanide and i don't know why

  • My birthday is July 3rd!

  • Matt looks awesome! Good for him!!

  • Spencer to Tomey was basically “Can you fit a whole cupcake in your mouth 😏”

  • Team Spemmy is better than Team Sperm.

  • I just love how grown adults are saying " it's poo poo"

  • markiplier if he had blue hair. looks cool tho

  • OMG im born 3 july tooo. BESTIESSSS

  • In New Zealand we had a pizza roulette where 1 slice would have the hottest chili oil/sauce, but you couldn't visibly see which slice had it. One guy I saw eat it ran outside and vomited cos it was so hot...You could do a version of this where half the slices are hot (or disgusting) and the rest are normal

  • Sarah was such a mood popping that Lactaid pill before eating the cupcake (pretty sure I'm remembering right that she is lactose intolerant)

  • Lmao , that was quite hilarious and also disgusting

  • Fill empanadas.

  • Shayne knows the fourth wish trick from… experience

  • Do cake pops!!!! Try to include different candies next time in the cupcakes (pop rocks, sour candies, chocolate, ghost pepper)

  • Tommy: "Its benign" I lost it. 💀

  • Ima bills fan sadly


  • Matt seems like he's getting nicer in these videos & that makes for better watching. 😊

  • next time do ghost pepper in one of them

  • I really hope Kimmy gets a good cupcake, I can’t handle watching her have a bad time

  • Whoever colored Sarah's hair needs a raise, she looks fabulous!

  • But, what was in kimmys??

  • LMFAO HOLY SHIT SHANE 3:57 "That's how you get FOUR wishes from a Genie." GAT DAYUMN 10/10 joke of the month

  • If I learned anything from this it's that Spencer's birthday is 3 days before mine

  • what mario party is this?

  • You could have brownies in a mug

  • Ian, you're such a troll, and I have that much more respect for you, brother! LMBO!

  • Spencer to Sarah “do you think you could fit the whole cupcake in you mouth” Damien *again with this?🤨* lol

  • Sarah keeps getting Mike Wazowski'd and I'm living for it.

  • Am I the only one that doesn’t know the flavor of Kimmy’s cupcake? They didn’t say it, did they?


  • thank u editing team for blurring the spitting out, i'm emetophobic and even when they LOOK like they're gonna chunder my stomach turns, it's appreciated!!


  • 11:10 Damien predicted the future AGAIN

  • That's how you get 4 wishes from a genie😂 oh my, gosh I can't 😂

  • OKAY BUT SARAH LOOKS AMAZING! The hair? The makeup? THE BLAZER? Hi I'll play Mario with you, Sarah.

  • Anyone else just have the BIGGEST crush on Tommy? can I have him? Is he single? ❤️😍💕

  • Canned clams, wasabi, jello, pickles

  • I swear sarah at the end looked like Harley. Not joker face, Harley craze

  • Yo put some Vegemite in a cupcake. I love seeing non Australians suffer

  • I haven’t been keeping up to date watching smosh and Matt Raub looks like he’s lost some weight, also props to Ian’s acting skills did not know he was lying

  • i still wanna know what the good red cupcake was

  • Ian admiting he got the bad one is same energy with a toddler saying "I made a poopy"

  • Sarah needs to tell us what lipstick shes using cause my gawd its beautiful 😲

  • I know it’s been awhile since I’ve watched Smosh Games, but dang Matt has definitely lost some weight.

  • 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

  • guys i love you i really do but you really do not need to add challenge at the end of every title please i’m begging you at this point

  • Garret needs to step up his game, those cupcakes on the title screen looked way better! I’d want to eat them bad ones and all if they looked like that.

  • Power move from spencer

  • Oh Damn.....Matt Raub lost some weight. Good for him......

  • has anyone else legitimately seen this video before???? is this deja vu or just a really similar video??? im so lost

    • I FIGURED IT OUT, its from the 15 year anniversary stream lmaoo

  • Sees Matt Raub. Looks for another vid.

  • I am a master at hearing things wrong. This time i heard "my birth taste like cupcake" insted of burp xD

  • No one: Nobody: Spencer: Can you fit the whole cupcake in your mouth?

  • Dude, Matt has lost so much weight. Good for him!

  • Chocolate covered apples and chocolate covered onions

  • Forgot"ANTHONY

  • Damiens getting so fat. He just rolls in the studio wearing 3x sweatpants everytime lmaoo

  • Pasturised Raw egg / edible raw egg in one of the foods would be amazing to watch them suffer >: D

  • When Spencer fit the whole cupcake in his mouth...the look of regret after had me screaming. Poor Spencer 🤣🤣

  • 3:25 Spencer killed me lol

  • sarahs hair is amazing

  • I didn't recognize matt.. He's so much leaner!

  • From the 15th anniversary Stream

  • The Peamup Bubber is giving me Baman Piderman vibes

  • The look spencer gave Shayne while eating the cupcake was really adorable 😂😂😂

  • matt looks amazing omg why is no one talking about this

  • Where has Olivia been did she quit

  • Minced garlic filled cupcakes

  • Mmmm spicy guacamole

  • I accidentally had my playback at 2x speed and let me tell you watching the intro in that way was a wild ride.

  • Odd flavors of gum

  • Honestly I'm kinda shocked there wasn't even one spicy boy in there 🤣

  • These challenges are always fun to watch but I think they should use something worse than mustard or mayo. I feel like they could be a bit more creative with the punishment foods.

  • Nothing worse than when your dad wears skinny jeans with holes in the knees and dyes his hair, just get a Lamborghini and get it over with , I’m not talking about Ian we all know he has hair plugs

  • love this episode of Eat it or Yeet it. Wait, wrong channel

  • Been awhile since I checked in with Smosh Games. Imagine showing this to someone 6 years ago

  • Matt took a tube and hooked it into Damien and transferred over all his fat

  • What was in the good red cupcake?

  • You guys should make a video on you guys being your funny adorable charming selfs unlocking the mysterious Mario party characters you don't have and unlocking anything else you don't have. It would be helpful and funny. Boom idea 😅♥

  • One serving pies

  • Matt wearing the Snowrambe hoodie brings back good memories

  • Should have made a cupcake out of a biscuit and iced it, that's surprising.

  • I was having some crazy deja vu. And was worried but I remembered this was on a stream I think

  • Spencer looked like a kid who just got caught sneaking food by their parents 🤣💜